Sunday, July 17, 2011

Book Review: Disrupted Lives

Prologue: Hmm ... Have you ever read a prologue to a book review? Hey, somebody's gotta go first and it may as well be me! My friend Brenda will confirm that I do not care for prologues in books ... smiles. With that in mind, here's my introduction to my review of "Disrupted Lives" by my friend and author, Brenda Youngerman:

I am going to break my self-imposed rules for writing a book review. Rarely do I get personal in a book review; seldom will you see me use the word "I" in a book review; and, it is an extremely rare occasion when I review the author as opposed to, or along with, reviewing the book. In the case of this particular author, this particular book title, I have made the decision to review both the book and the author -- from my personal point of view. I justify my breaking of my review rules by the fact that my author friend is worthy of my doing so, which I shall explain further in the review.


----------


"Disrupted Lives" by author Brenda Youngerman is the telling across generations of the lifespan of the Lake and Kane families. It is a work of fiction with a purpose, as all of Youngerman's novels are appraised to be.

Having read a few of Youngerman's novels and many of her other writings, I have come to expect and appreciate her desire to make a difference with her writing talent. Brenda seldom scribes for pleasure and even in so doing, social issues rise within her writings. Her compassion for others, for society as a whole, is evident in each of her works.

"Disrupted Lives" touches on matters that directly or indirectly affect not just the characters in the family of the book, but these are also concerns you and I live with every day. Adoption, culture, racism, relationships, family values, and family secrets are just a few of the topics we take a look at through the pages of this historic journey Youngerman takes us on.

From Fiona, the matriarch of the Lake family on down to her grandson of the Kane clan, we see generations of the families affected long term by their own decisions and by the choices of other family members. The life of family was torn apart by paths chosen.

Need and Greed are the two major implied forces battling within the Lake and Kane families. I was pretty sure the adopted grandson managed to affect change until the ending of the story of these families. In the end, I feel Youngerman failed somewhat to convince me that the parents sought their long lost son for any reason other than need and greed. Sure, I was convinced they loved him; I was more convinced they loved their daughter more -- her Need was their Greed. The wheels of the unjust are a perpetual motion, thriving and harmful across generations.

However, I do not believe this is the reaction author Brenda Youngerman hoped for, wrote for. It is my belief that her words for her characters, Darren and Amelia, on two or three separate occasions, could have been chosen more wisely, more precisely, to her purpose.

On the back cover of "Disrupted Lives" you will read: A name does not make a person, a person makes a name. Without a doubt, Brenda Youngerman is making a name for herself in her novels. I do not pretend to be an expert on the art of writing, but I know enough to be able to say this author has talent. She writes with a passionate pen. Each book of this author's I have read has shown writing growth and improvement. (I like this in an author and it may well be the reason I prefer to read and review newer published authors as opposed to renowned authors.)

"Disrupted Lives" has a style all its own, a passion all its own. This Brenda Youngerman title is one you will want to own.


----------


This book review was written as part of the Disrupted Lives - Blog Tour.

I received a copy of the book from the author for review purposes.

For your convenience, I have provided you with a link to purchase your copy of this book from Amazon.com:



13 comments:

  1. This is an excellent review, and I agree with you completely - Brenda's passion certainly is evident in her writing. This was the first of Brenda's writing that I have read and I am looking forward to reading more (hoping for a sequel!)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hoping for a sequel, myself, Bonnie. And Brenda's and Amelia left room for one in the end lines of the book. Wouldn't you just love to know how she ended up at Wayward House?!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent review my friend!
    And who knows....Amelia's story? Perhaps....

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks, Brenda, and like I've often said: a good book makes for a good book review.

    Amelia's story ... hopefully!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Well, we did find out how she ended up at the Wayward House didn't we? Her parents were ashamed that she got pregnant and sent her away to have the baby---her not knowing she wasn't going to get to keep the child.
    What I like best about Brenda's books is how she intertwines everyone's lives within the book.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I beg to differ in regards to Amelia and Dareen need versus greed. I don't think greed was ever in the picture. If it was they could of contacted him way before his half sister life threatening NEED for a kidney. How about contacting him to help with his half sister and brother college funds, or a new house or furniture. No i don't think it was about Greed. Any woman or person that know there is a possible match that could save a life would be out searching and making contact also. Need and Greed can not exist together, however Greed and Want can.

    ReplyDelete
  7. NOW .... this is what I call a blog tour!! Thanks Sidne.... I agree ... I didn't write it with Need and Greed and if Darren and Amelia were greedy in any way ... it never came out my pen.... they never asked for anything and her parents certainly had it! So did his. So, I am 100% behind Sidne on this one!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Sidne, I appreciate your comments and do understand where you're coming from. Brenda, as I said in my review, I did not feel this was your intent.

    My thoughts are not need versus greed, they are need AND greed, and not monetary greed. Need for their daughter was the driving force of contact with their son, is how I read it... First phone contact: Sophia takes a call for Ben, tells him the call is on line 3, "She said your sister is critical and needs you." Ben goes to the phone thinking it is about his sister Prudence and is told,"I believe you have another sister." Ben listens further to hear, "Honestly Ben, I don't want money at all. I need one of your kidneys." It is then explained how she arrived at believing he is her son, taken from her at birth...

    Having a father last seen at age three, I will tell you that if a man called me and said that to me right now, I'd ask him where the heck he's been all my life and hate him (all over again) for contacting me only when he "needed" me, NOT before, NOT because of love for me, NO, only because of love for the daughter.

    I just didn't see the same strength in this situational writing that I saw throughout the book.

    ReplyDelete
  9. OOPs! That should read "at age 3 days" not at age 3.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hey Marsha! Yes, we do know how she ended up at Wayward and all that occurred afterwards. I think we want the "back story" and the love story from the beginning.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Great review, and I like how you included your own thoughts. I struggle to decide when to include me in my reviews but it really works here.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks for reading the review, Sheila. I'm glad it worked this time, as I said, I usually don't include my "self" in my book reviews. It's a tough call of when and when not to do so.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for your comments.
Blessings & a bit o' sunshine!